infoTECH Spotlight Magazine

infoTECH Magazine


October 01, 2011

Freedom vs. Security

This article originally appeared in the Oct. 2011 issue of InfoTECH

There is no doubt that the Internet has been the most revolutionary invention of the 20th century. Never before has a human invention given so much freedom to so many people: digital access to information of all kind everywhere in the world. Today, more people get their news from the Internet than from newspapers; young people are watching more online video than broadcast TV; everyone can develop their own blogs and let the world know about their lives, thoughts and opinions.

However, it seems that the Internet as we know it today has its days numbered. Over the next few years we are going to witness several attempts to gag the Net. But, wait a second: we live in a free world, don’t we? Well, sort of, given that if you want to start your own radio or TV station you will have to ask your government for the corresponding license. And yet, today anybody can create a blog, or start an online radio or TV station to voice their opinions without needing to ask anybody’s permission.

But there is more. People are using the Internet to coordinate protests against repressive regimes, and social networking sites like Twitter (News - Alert) show the power of the Internet, a place where you can hear other people’s voices and they can hear yours.

Governments are scared. Very scared. Traditional dictatorships have always known how “dangerous” the Internet is, censoring its contents. In 2011 we have seen many examples of governments’ attempts to eradicate this problem once and for all like, for example, when former Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarak shut down the country’s Internet connection and mobile phone network. A few days later he was forced to step down as president. Even some Western governments have started to consider the possibility of having a “kill switch” to shut down the Internet at will, with the excuse of protecting the country against cyber-attacks.

The issue of freedom versus security is in everybody’s mouth, and a majority of people believe it is worth giving up some individual rights in exchange for security. Benjamin Franklin expressed his view of the issue many years ago:

“People willing to trade their freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both.”

Today many people unfortunately don’t even know who Benjamin Franklin was. What’s more, many of them are very happy to trade their own freedom in exchange for a certain sense of security (whether real or not, the important thing is to think that you are safe).

Moreover, if those taking your liberties from you have been democratically elected, then people are more than happy to accept it. Once we have reached this point I think it is a good idea to quote Lenin’s opinion about freedom in order to avoid past mistakes:

“It is true that liberty is precious, so precious that it must be carefully rationed.”

And that’s exactly the key point. We must stay forever vigilant in preserving our liberties from politicians wanting to control them in the name of security.

All this will eventually change the Internet as we currently know it – for worse at least when it comes to freedom of speech. In a few years’ time, besides protecting ourselves against cyber-attacks we will also have to look for mechanisms that guarantee our rights against government abuse of power. Some people are talking about the introduction of “Internet passports” to identify Internet users. This idea, widely applauded by some security experts, is sincerely nonsensical if not completely ridiculous. Does anybody really think that the existence of passports actually prevents crime, or that not having a driver’s license is going to keep some people from driving? The aim of this measure is to have people under control at all times.

Today our fight for freedom is more important than ever. Nobody should have the power to limit our freedom in the name of security. Whether I am right or wrong, what I truly want is to have the right to choose freely, even if it is just to make a mistake.

Luis Corrons is PandaLabs technical director at Panda Security (News - Alert).

TMCnet publishes expert commentary on various telecommunications, IT, call center, CRM and other technology-related topics. Are you an expert in one of these fields, and interested in having your perspective published on a site that gets several million unique visitors each month? Get in touch.

Edited by Stefania Viscusi